Explain why ethnic minorities in the Soviet Union were persecuted in the years 1924–41.
30 Russia and the Soviet Union, 1917–41
Edexcel GCSE History · 1HI0/30 November 2021, Question 2
More questions on this topic
Practise the whole topic →1HI0/30November 2021Question 14 marks~5 min Study Source A below and then answer Question 1.
Source A A Soviet propaganda poster created in 1938. The poster was published with the slogan, ‘Glory to the Great Stalin!’
Give two things you can infer from Source A about Stalin as a leader.
Complete the table below to explain your answer.
Answer frame
- (i) What I can infer
- Details in the source that tell me this
- (ii) What I can infer
- Details in the source that tell me this
1HI0/30November 2021Question 3(a)8 marks~10 min Study Sources B and C.
Source BFrom a statement made by the Kronstadt sailors in March 1921, during the Kronstadt Mutiny. The statement was called ‘What Are We Fighting For?’. The working classes carried out the October Revolution, and afterwards hoped for freedom. The result, however, has been greater slavery. The Bolsheviks have crushed the peasant revolts and worker strikes with great violence and bloodshed. They have used force and have imprisoned people. The Bolsheviks no longer represent the workers. They have insulted the glorious symbols of the workers’ state: the hammer and the sickle. Here in Kronstadt, we are making another revolution which will free the workers and the Soviets from the Bolsheviks.
Source CFrom a pamphlet written by Lenin in 1921. Here he is explaining the New Economic Policy (NEP) to the Soviet people. The workers and peasants, who have made enormous sacrifices, are totally exhausted. After many years of war, they are unable to work. We were forced to bring in ‘War Communism’ to save us from ruin. It was a temporary measure. Introducing the NEP is now necessary. It will bring back small private industry. It will improve our economy. It will allow peasants to sell their surplus grain. However, our revolution is not threatened by these changes. We must not lose heart, for we shall win through in the end.
How useful are Sources B and C for an enquiry into the challenges facing the Bolsheviks in the years 1921–24?
Explain your answer, using Sources B and C and your knowledge of the historical context.
1HI0/30November 2021Question 3(b)4 marks~5 min Study Interpretations 1 and 2. They give different views about the challenges facing the Bolsheviks in the years 1921–24.
Interpretation 1From The Russian Revolution by T Pimlott, published in 1985. In 1921, after three years of War Communism, Russia was in chaos. There was widespread disease and starvation. Industry was producing less than it had before the Revolution. In an effort to restore order, Lenin introduced his New Economic Policy (NEP). The NEP allowed peasants to keep their land and sell off any surplus food they grew. It also allowed some industries to return to private ownership. The NEP allowed the Bolsheviks some time to recover before a real Socialist state could be set up.
Interpretation 2From Russia by M Sixsmith, published in 2012. The Kronstadt Mutiny was a warning that Lenin could not ignore. The Mutiny gave a focus to the anger of workers and peasants, who felt disappointed by the Bolsheviks. Lenin admitted the Bolsheviks were only just hanging on to power. He told the Tenth Party Congress meeting that the peasant revolts and the Kronstadt Mutiny were more dangerous to the Bolsheviks than the Whites were. The people were no longer willing to suffer in the hope of a better future. The Bolsheviks’ use of terror and military force was no longer enough to keep control.
What is the main difference between these views?
Explain your answer, using details from both interpretations.
1HI0/30November 2021Question 3(c)4 marks~5 min Interpretation 1From The Russian Revolution by T Pimlott, published in 1985. In 1921, after three years of War Communism, Russia was in chaos. There was widespread disease and starvation. Industry was producing less than it had before the Revolution. In an effort to restore order, Lenin introduced his New Economic Policy (NEP). The NEP allowed peasants to keep their land and sell off any surplus food they grew. It also allowed some industries to return to private ownership. The NEP allowed the Bolsheviks some time to recover before a real Socialist state could be set up.
Interpretation 2From Russia by M Sixsmith, published in 2012. The Kronstadt Mutiny was a warning that Lenin could not ignore. The Mutiny gave a focus to the anger of workers and peasants, who felt disappointed by the Bolsheviks. Lenin admitted the Bolsheviks were only just hanging on to power. He told the Tenth Party Congress meeting that the peasant revolts and the Kronstadt Mutiny were more dangerous to the Bolsheviks than the Whites were. The people were no longer willing to suffer in the hope of a better future. The Bolsheviks’ use of terror and military force was no longer enough to keep control.
Source BFrom a statement made by the Kronstadt sailors in March 1921, during the Kronstadt Mutiny. The statement was called ‘What Are We Fighting For?’. The working classes carried out the October Revolution, and afterwards hoped for freedom. The result, however, has been greater slavery. The Bolsheviks have crushed the peasant revolts and worker strikes with great violence and bloodshed. They have used force and have imprisoned people. The Bolsheviks no longer represent the workers. They have insulted the glorious symbols of the workers’ state: the hammer and the sickle. Here in Kronstadt, we are making another revolution which will free the workers and the Soviets from the Bolsheviks.
Source CFrom a pamphlet written by Lenin in 1921. Here he is explaining the New Economic Policy (NEP) to the Soviet people. The workers and peasants, who have made enormous sacrifices, are totally exhausted. After many years of war, they are unable to work. We were forced to bring in ‘War Communism’ to save us from ruin. It was a temporary measure. Introducing the NEP is now necessary. It will bring back small private industry. It will improve our economy. It will allow peasants to sell their surplus grain. However, our revolution is not threatened by these changes. We must not lose heart, for we shall win through in the end.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the challenges facing the Bolsheviks in the years 1921–24.
You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
1HI0/30November 2021Question 3(d)20 marks~25 min Interpretation 1From The Russian Revolution by T Pimlott, published in 1985. In 1921, after three years of War Communism, Russia was in chaos. There was widespread disease and starvation. Industry was producing less than it had before the Revolution. In an effort to restore order, Lenin introduced his New Economic Policy (NEP). The NEP allowed peasants to keep their land and sell off any surplus food they grew. It also allowed some industries to return to private ownership. The NEP allowed the Bolsheviks some time to recover before a real Socialist state could be set up.
Interpretation 2From Russia by M Sixsmith, published in 2012. The Kronstadt Mutiny was a warning that Lenin could not ignore. The Mutiny gave a focus to the anger of workers and peasants, who felt disappointed by the Bolsheviks. Lenin admitted the Bolsheviks were only just hanging on to power. He told the Tenth Party Congress meeting that the peasant revolts and the Kronstadt Mutiny were more dangerous to the Bolsheviks than the Whites were. The people were no longer willing to suffer in the hope of a better future. The Bolsheviks’ use of terror and military force was no longer enough to keep control.
How far do you agree with Interpretation 2 about the challenges facing the Bolsheviks in the years 1921–24?
Explain your answer, using both interpretations and your knowledge of the historical context.
Spelling, punctuation, grammar and use of specialist terminology will be assessed in part (d). · Total for spelling, punctuation, grammar and use of specialist terminology = 4 marks